When we were young, our mother told us that cellar door, despite its mundane meaning, was widely considered to be one of the most beautiful phrases in the English language. Along with this bit of phonaesthetic trivia, Mom instilled in us a lifelong love of language, a passion for reading, and an enthusiasm for sharing our stories.

So while cellar door may conjure up an image of a blistered-paint Bilco monstrosity, threshold to a dank den of menacing spiders and crazy-hopping cave crickets, we hope that The Cellar Door Book Society becomes a place for friends and fellow readers to gather, a place to discover books that sound good... a place to find enjoyable, worthwhile reads.

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Auld Lang Syne-off: Parting Words from Our 2014 Bookshelf

All the Light We Cannot See: A Novel by Anthony Doerr
Scribner, 2014.  531 pages.
Historical Fiction
Our Been-There-Read-That Bookshelf fairly brims with moderately memorable historical fiction: a few pages into this one, we realize we’re reading something beyond the moderately memorable.  Set in World War II Germany and France, revealed through deftly intertwined narratives, this National Book Award Finalist concerns itself with the internal lives of two adolescents—a sightless French girl and a gifted German boy—as they negotiate a broken, brutal external world.  Blind since early childhood, Marie-Laure lives in Paris with her father, master locksmith at the Museum of Natural History.  When the Nazis occupy Paris, father and daughter flee to the coastal citadel of Saint-Malo.  Werner Pfennig grows up in a German orphanage, demonstrating precocious aptitude for radio technology.  His talents earn him admission to a blood-chilling academy for Hitler Youth, and Werner soon finds himself journeying through the dark heart of war, eventually to Saint-Malo.  As Marie-Laure and Werner move toward inevitable meeting on the Brittany coast, abbreviated chapters present big themes and intricate detail with prose that is at once sweeping and tightly composed.  The result is luminous historical fiction: All the Light We Cannot See achieves a convergence of history and personal experience that lingers in our memory long after the last page turns.  

Parting Words: She listens until his footsteps fade.  Until all she can hear are the sighs of cars and the rumble of trains and the sounds of everyone hurrying through the cold.

Badluck Way: A Year on the Ragged Edge of the West by Bryce Andrews.
Atria Books, 2014.  238 pages.
Non Fiction and Biographies
A mid-summer book drought ends with this compelling memoir by a first-time author-cum-ranch-hand. The story is set just north of Yellowstone in the windswept Madison Valley, an area we have hiked, a remote landscape we—like the author—feel connection to.  Time and again, we have happened upon bleached bones strewn across sublime Montana trail and therefore understand apprehensions experienced by one charged with safeguarding cattle contiguous to a wild, natural place... the conflict between idealism and pragmatism in a land of predators and domesticated prey.  Without this connection, one may be tempted to reduce this story to: got a job as a ranch hand, worked like a dog for a year, and killed a wolf.  But more probably, even those with no particular fondness for wild and natural places will appreciate Andrews’ description of the daunting frontier.  And even those with no previous experience in fence building, with no burning interest in riding the range and caring for cattle, will benefit from his reflection upon the complications of shared environmental space: the inescapable variance between conservation of wilderness and relentless encroachment by… us.

Parting Words: I am still haunted by the endless grassy sweep of the Madison Valley, the herds of elk that move like clouds across it, and the wolves running creek bottoms in the morning half light.

The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles, and Their Secret World War by Stephen Kinzer.
Henry Holt and Company, 2013.
Nonfiction and Biography
It happens once a year: we get a hankering for an intellectually provocative journalistic critique of historically significant-yet-under-examined voraciously anti-communist siblings.  Go figure!  John Foster Dulles (serious, matrimonially faithful Secretary of State) and Allen Dulles (gregarious, seriously callow CIA Director) have been summarily scuttled from our collective national memory.  Why?  Because, to be painfully succinct, they f-ed up.  But their dual biography is an important, if slightly tedious, reading experience.  Shaped by a raging missionary mentality, a politicized pioneer spirit, and fervent belief in American exceptionalism, the Brothers Dulles were convinced that Good-with-a-capital-G and Evil-with-a-capital-E were at war in the mid-twentieth century world—and that they had providential calling to fight the covert fight.  

Parting Words: They are us.  We are them.

The Goldfinch: A Novel by Donna Tartt.
Little, Brown and Company, 2013.  771 pages.
The Pulitzer Project
Early in the year, we do the heavy lifting and hoist this big, captivating, lovely-but-flawed coming-of-age story from the shelf. A cataclysmic moment of violence launches Our Protagonist Narrator on a so-tragic-it’s-comedic life trajectory, an exhausting physical and psychological journey from youth to adulthood and, for us, an exhausting flight of heart-and-mind-flipping fiction.  Despite many maddening contradictions, The Goldfinch wins our hearts and minds, most of the time.  It is slow to build but moves at an urgent pace.  It is long… but not too long.  It is large and loud and trenchant and sprawling, nothing like the small and subdued and subtle, intimately-rendered titular painting—but married to it in eloquent ways.  When we come to the end, we take the Pulitzer Prize winner—with its loss and love, ugliness and beauty, sorrow and survival, ruin and redemption—wrap it with newspaper, seal it with duct tape, put it in a pillowcase, then in a shopping bag, and store it on a hopeful shelf in the climate-controlled recesses of the Cellar Door.

Parting Words: I add my own love to the history of people who have loved beautiful things, and looked out for them, and pulled them from the fire, and sought them when they were lost, and tried to preserve them and save them while passing them along literally from hand to hand, singing out brilliantly from the wreck of time to the next generation of lovers, and the next.

The Good Lord Bird by James McBride.
Riverhead Books, 2013.  417 pages.
Historical Fiction
Here we have an imaginative convergence of Brink-of-Civil-War history, slapstick comedy, rip-roaring adventure and, ultimately, heartfelt exploration of appearance and reality, race and identity, action and inaction—all with a Twain-like tone.  And Good Lord, we have two unforgettable characters: narrator Henry Shackleford, a young slave in Kansas Territory, and controversial abolitionist John Brown.  An early-in-the-action argument between Brown and Shackleford’s master turns predictably violent and, before we can murmur Huckleberry Finn, young Henry is on the run with Brown—disguised as a girl and nicknamed Little Onion—rollicking across a blood-stained, socially-strained landscape toward a definitive moment at Harper’s Ferry.  Was John Brown a madman or a martyr, a terrorist wreaking havoc through armed insurrection, or a visionary executing God’s wrathful will?  The Good Lord Bird will not silence historical debate, but Little Onion’s narrative voice imbues Brown with flesh-and-blood humanity, and the story reverberates with grace, humor, and genuine wisdom.

Parting Words: Up above the church, high above it, a strange black and white bird circled ‘round, looking for a tree to roost on, a bad tree, I expect, so he could alight upon it and get busy, so that it would someday fall and feed the others.

The Luminaries by Eleanor Catton.
Little, Brown and Company, 2013.  834 pages.
Fiction Favorites
During the Dog Days of summer, we enjoy this beguiling behemoth in the privacy of backyard shade: from the sequestered comfort of a weathered Adirondack chair, with an outdoor cushion for lumbar support, a cold compress to sooth throbbing temples, and a tall glass of something iced within reach.  A few dense pages into this Man Booker Prize Winner, we recognize themes requisite to the Victorian sensation novel, updated with a crisp, postmodern tone.  Adultery?  Check.  Amateur Sleuthing?  Check.  Apparitions?  Check.  Concealed Gold?  Check.  Forgery?  Check.  Illicit Opium Use?  Check.  How about Murder?  Prostitution?  Seances?  Seduction?  Sketchy Behaviors?  Thievery?  Check, check, check, check, check… check!  The plot thickens meticulously, and much of the story is set in nineteenth-century Hokitika, New Zealand.  In the language of the Maori, Hokitika means around, and then back again—an appellation explaining much about the novel’s elaborate, circular narrative path.  The plot revolves around planetary movements, and characters correspond to zodiac signs. The opening chapter is hundreds of pages long; the final chapter, just two.  Dickensian chapter headings wax as the page count wanes, synopsis eclipsing narrative in the closing pages.  A fascinating read, a good read... but pass the cold compress and the tall glass of something iced, please.

Parting Words: “Are your eyes closed?” “Yes.  Are Yours?”  “Yes.  Though it’s so dark it hardly makes a difference.”  “I feel—more than myself.”  “I feel—as though a new chamber of my heart has opened.”  “Listen.”  “What is it?”  “The rain.”

Mary Coin by Marisa Silver.
Plume, 2014.  322 pages.
Historical Fiction
One moment in time: In Nipomo, California, 1936, a young mother sits roadside, surrounded by a cluster of ragged, clinging children.  Another woman emerges from an automobile and approaches, photographic equipment in hand.  Charged with documenting the plight of migrant agricultural laborers, she raises her camera, clicks the shutter, capturing the tableau in black and white—an iconic image of Depression-era America. A great photograph speaks to us viscerally, intellectually, historically.  But can it move beyond the moment to illuminate a life—or does it, in static poignancy, obscure both truth and reality? Mary Coin expands upon that moment in time, exploring both the potency and limitations of photographic art. The woman with the camera, Vera Dare, is drawn from real-life photographer-of-note Dorothea Lange.  The young mother, Mary Coin, is derived from the original Migrant Mother, Florence Owens Thompson.  Throw in a fictional current-day professor of cultural history who is researching a family secret, and we have a a smooth and satisfying late-year read to stash on the shelf.

Parting Words: The picture slides down the screen and disappears.  But it will always exist.  In a cloud.  In an invisible language of zeros and ones.  There is no erasure.

Savage Harvest: A Tale of Cannibals, Colonialism, and Michael Rockefeller’s Tragic Quest for Primitive Art by Carl Hoffman.
HarperCollins Publishers, 2014.  322 pages.
Nonfiction and Biography
Mid-year, we pull page-turning nonfiction off the shelf.  In late 1961, twenty-three-year-old Michael Rockefeller—great-grandson of Standard Oil magnate John D. Rockefeller and son of then-New York Governor Nelson Rockefeller—vanished without a trace in dangerous waters off the southwest coast of New Guinea.  Young Rockefeller had been on an artifact-collecting expedition for his father’s recently-founded Museum of Primitive Art when his catamaran capsized while crossing a turbulent river mouth.  An expedition partner stayed with the boat and was rescued, but Michael reportedly made a swim for terra firma and disappeared.  Before long, wild rumors began circulating: Rockefeller had indeed reached shore, only to be killed and consumed by native Asmat, warrior tribesmen with lifeways built around retributional violence, headhunting, and ritual cannibalism… locals who knew Rockefeller by name.  Retracing Michael’s ill-fated progress, an author-journalist ventures into remote New Guinean jungles, shedding light on a generational whodunit that at once confounded the Dutch colonial government and aggrieved one of the world’s most powerful families. 

Parting Words: Even for a stone ax  or a necklace of dog’s teeth, do not ever share this story.

The Snow Leopard by Peter Matthiessen
Penguin, 2008 (1978).  226 pages.
History and Travel
Peter Matthiessen, Great American novelist, naturalist, travel writer (and CIA agent!) passed away in April.  In fitting reading tribute, we visit one of his finest: a first-person chronicle of an eighty-five day trek through the rarefied heart of the Himalayas. While the ostensible objective of the trip is to join a fellow naturalist in a study of the mating habits of the Himalayan Blue Sheep, Matthiessen gives us more than Bharal bacchanal.  He describes the Dolpo Region of the Tibetan Plateau in evocative detail: the lay of the land, the people, the flora and fauna… the air up there.  He shares his oft-thwarted search for the elusive snow leopard, his equally oft-thwarted search for the equally elusive Lama of Shay, believed to be the modern incarnation of a twelfth-century Buddhist spiritual leader.  He meditates upon the death of his wife; he meditates upon the Buddhist principle of peace through acceptance.  He meditates, albeit briefly, upon the existence and range of the Yeti.  Matthiessen has left us, but The Snow Leopard holds a special place on the shelf, a luminous recollection of travel and transformation, a lyrical rumination upon external and internal life-journeying.

Parting Words: Under the Bodhi Eye, I get on my bicycle again and return along gray December roads to Kathmandu.

The Son by Philipp Meyer.
Ecco Press, 2013.  561 pages.
Fiction Favorites
Ranchers and Indians and Oilmen, oh my!  Eli McCullough claims the fictional distinction of being the first male child born in the newly–formed Texas Republic.  Captured by the Comanches, returned to the white man’s world, torn between two irreconcilable cultures, Eli parlays ruthless ambition, uncompromising hardheadedness, unflinching resilience, and heart-rending wit into an accumulation of wealth and power that twines across the McCullough family tree.  Eli’s narrative intermingles with time-traveling narratives of Peter and Jeannie, a sensitive son and a high-strung great-granddaughter whose lives unfold in considerable shadows cast by the family patriarch.  The Son claims a Texas-size chunk of shelf space: a smart, passionate, violent, panoramic generational epic, a coming of ages and ages and ages saga as ambitious and absorbing as the House of McCullough.

Parting Words: A child like that would be worth a thousand men today.  We left him standing in the riverbank.  As far as I know, he is looking for me yet.


That's all they wrote... and some of what we read in 2014. 
Happy New Year and Happy Reading in 2015!

No comments:

Post a Comment